EgyptSearch Forums: Post A Reply

...

»	EgyptSearch Forums » Egyptology » Enough with the OT crap! » Post A Reply

T O P I C R E V I E W
Wally Member # 2936	posted This is a forum that is supposed to be about Ancient Egypt and Egyptology, but it seems to be open field for those, usually ill-informed, who wish to post topics that are besides the point. If you don't know or are not interested in Ancient Egypt...go somewhere's else...Please?
Mustafino Member # 12795	posted No more Olmecs, Chinese, etc? Wohoo!!!!
Bettyboo Member # 12987	posted How long can you talk about Ancient Egypt. Once everything is discussed and there's nothing else to talk about people will eventually start making up folklore, lies, and hocus pocus science.
Djehuti Member # 6698	posted quote: Enough with the OT crap! I couldn't agree more! When I first returned to this forum, the first thing I noticed was a long list of way off-topic threads mostly having to do "black issues". No offense, but this is not blackplanet or BET.com! And of course there are those start threads based on pseudo-sht nonsense!! I'm not naming any names, but you know who they are. I would like to discuss more about ancient Egypt and/or Egyptology. I would find off-topic threads far more interesting if they were not too off and had something* to do with Egypt whether ancient or modern.
Bettyboo Member # 12987	posted I'm tired of all these black mumbo jumbo crap that has nothing to do with Ancient Egypt. This forum should have at least 1000 threads about "ancient Egypt" and I would like if we can continue that. Thanks for your cooperation.
ausar Member # 1797	posted Off-topic posts are okay but become rather redundant when they out number the ones on ancient Egypt. Please consider also that sometimes the dry academic talk often on this forum is either over somebody's head or boring so they eventually post off-topic. Nothing wrong with a balance of off-topic posts alongside the more serious discussion. If you want to get more people posting about ancient Egypt you have to make it more exciting and include some more common language. Don't comnpletely dumb down posts or talk down to posters but know the right balance. Personally, I have a difficult time writing in a way to lure people in unless its dry academic writing.
King_Scorpion Member # 4818	posted No offense, but until I see some sort of rule that OT threads can't be made...I couldn't care less what people are getting tired of, but that's just me.
alTakruri Member # 10195	posted If anyone is insensed with OT threads I suggest they contribute to existing on topic threads or broach their own on topic threads. As simple as that. Otherwise sit, sulk, and stew in your own juices.
Technical Anomaly (What Box) Member # 10819	posted ^Wise words, Takruri. quote: Originally posted by alTakruri: I'm pleading for moderation to delete all off topic threads. .. pretty.. corroborating! quote: ausar: [...]Personally, I have a difficult time writing in a way to lure people in unless its dry academic writing. Lay Man writes: What! Nah-ah! I can read quite a bit of your posts. Very thoughtful of you, though.
Clyde Winters Member # 10129	posted quote: Originally posted by ausar: Off-topic posts are okay but become rather redundant when they out number the ones on ancient Egypt. Please consider also that sometimes the dry academic talk often on this forum is either over somebody's head or boring so they eventually post off-topic. Nothing wrong with a balance of off-topic posts alongside the more serious discussion. If you want to get more people posting about ancient Egypt you have to make it more exciting and include some more common language. Don't comnpletely dumb down posts or talk down to posters but know the right balance. Personally, I have a difficult time writing in a way to lure people in unless its dry academic writing. Also, it would be good if the regulars allowed people to ask questions without attacking the questioners personally. .
Ebony Allen Member # 12771	posted I think the OT threads are interesting. I suggest a forum for one. For the ones above who don't like them why do you always post in them?
Ebony Allen Member # 12771	posted As for you Djehuti you say there have been a 1,000 posts dealing with black issues. Egypt was a black civilization. All the people were black. So if anyone talks about matters relating to Egypt they're still talking things that has to do with blacks.
Mustafino Member # 12795	posted quote: Originally posted by Ebony Allen: As for you Djehuti you say there have been a 1,000 posts dealing with black issues. Egypt was a black civilization. All the people were black. So if anyone talks about matters relating to Egypt they're still talking things that has to do with blacks. Eh, no. Just wishful thinking.
kifaru Member # 4698	posted quote: Originally posted by Clyde Winters: Also, it would be good if the regulars allowed people to ask questions without attacking the questioners personally. I agree. This forum has become somewhat poisoned by rudeness and lack of scholarly decorum. Not saying we're all scholars here but we should observe some kind of self restraint when there are differeing opinions.
sam p Member # 11774	posted Too many threads seem to get caught up on issues of race. A lot of people here are interested in race so this is obviously going to be a recurring theme but there's no need for it to invade every thread. Where it's off topic we could simply ignore it. Where it is the topic we can choose whether to contribute or ignore it. No doubt more might contribute if these threads were less rancorous.
James I. Nienhuis Member # 13209	posted I figured out how the Ancient Egyptians surveyed the Great Pyramid to be half a nautical mile, according to the rate of precession, and you guys sit there as if it's old news. I don't get it.
Djehuti Member # 6698	posted quote: Originally posted by Ebony Allen: As for you Djehuti you say there have been a 1,000 posts dealing with black issues. Egypt was a black civilization. All the people were black. So if anyone talks about matters relating to Egypt they're still talking things that has to do with blacks. Even if Egypt is a black African civilization, that does NOT mean one must create threads whose topics are about modern African American issues!
Djehuti Member # 6698	posted quote: Originally posted by sam p: Too many threads seem to get caught up on issues of race. A lot of people here are interested in race so this is obviously going to be a recurring theme but there's no need for it to invade every thread. Where it's off topic we could simply ignore it. Where it is the topic we can choose whether to contribute or ignore it. No doubt more might contribute if these threads were less rancorous. Indeed, there is more to the Egyptians than just their physical appearance or skin color but for some folks such a subject consumes their lives! quote: Originally posted by James I. Nienhuis: I figured out how the Ancient Egyptians surveyed the Great Pyramid to be half a nautical mile, according to the rate of precession, and you guys sit there as if it's old news. I don't get it. Sam P. just explained the reason why above. If you want, you can start a thread on it. I will be one of the few is actually interested in your findings. Just how accurate are you anyway, and are you the first to find this out?
Willing Thinker (What Box) Member # 10819	posted ^That's true, E.A. Sports, BUT Egypt was however an african civilization, so african topics that possibly bare any relevance, that are like, at least related to the continent are kind of relevant. I agree with D-J in that this is E.S., A.E. & E., and NOT B.E.T.!
sam p Member # 11774	posted quote: Originally posted by Djehuti: Sam P. just explained the reason why above. If you want, you can start a thread on it. I will be one of the few is actually interested in your findings. Just how accurate are you anyway, and are you the first to find this out? [/QB] I'm very interested as well but this was James I Nienhues' comment rather than mine. I nearly sympathized with him and asked for the info since I feel his pain. I figured someone would.
James I. Nienhuis Member # 13209	posted Djejuti, see the Precession Mapping and GP thread, and yes, I deduced the finding by distilling some work by Ralph Ellis, Crichton Miller, and Graham Hancock.
Wally Member # 2936	posted ...and PLEASE no more absurd topics like "Who Built the Egyptian Pyramids", it's like the old Groucho Marx joke "Who's buried in Grant's tomb?" Duhh, please think!! "Who built the Eifel Tower" - duhh, the French? "Who built the Great Wall of China" - duhh, the Chinese? "Who built the Empire State Building" - duhh, uhhh King Kong?, uhhh no, the Americans?
Djehuti Member # 6698	posted ^LOL So true!
Wally Member # 2936	posted I don't believe it, but it seems the O.T. crap is dwindling... I hope I didn't jinx things though