This is topic Sudan is Not an Arab Country in forum Egyptology at EgyptSearch Forums.


To visit this topic, use this URL:
http://www.egyptsearch.com/forums/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=8;t=004292

Posted by Africa (Member # 12142) on :
 
From the CIA Factbook website:

Ethnic groups:
black 52%, Arab 39%, Beja 6%, foreigners 2%, other 1%



Even the army is essentially non Arab

From today's New York Times article:
"Because Sudan’s large army is mostly made up of non-Arab foot soldiers who are unwilling to carry out brutal counterinsurgency tactics on fellow non-Arabs, the government has used Arab militias as ground troops in Darfur, paying them in cash and loot from the villages they raid. But now the fighting appears to be entering a new phase, in which the rebel groups, somewhat unified militarily under the banner of the National Redemption Front, are making increasingly brazen direct attacks on government troops.

From jamestown.org:

The development of the Janjawid is a direct consequence of the ethnic composition of the Sudanese regular army. For decades the regular Sudanese army has been largely formed (60-65%) from Kordofan Nubas and recruits from Darfur. Despite the civil war, the Sudanese army also relies on a large number of troops from the south. For all the rhetoric of jihad in Khartoum, service in the military appeals to few of the Nile-based Arabs who control the political process. With the Darfur troops considered politically unreliable in fighting their kinsmen, the government sought an alternative fighting force in Darfur that could be motivated by racial hatred.

AMR1 and SAC are typical of Sudanese Arabs: they know how to hide behind their computers and attack anything Black African but ultimately they are real coward.

plan2replan Copyright © 2006 Africa
 
Posted by Mystery Solver (Member # 9033) on :
 
I highly doubt that the poster "Sudan is an Arab country" is actually Sudanese.
 
Posted by AMR1 (Member # 7651) on :
 
60% of sudanese speak arabic as their mother tongue and adopt arabic culture, that is being arabic. arabism does not mean one's race.
 
Posted by ausar (Member # 1797) on :
 
You know I hear alot of people say what Amr say to justify their Arabness but never do they ask exactly what Arab culture is?


So I will ask Amr what is Arab culture? What Arab culture is in Sudan?
 
Posted by Sudan is an Arab country (Member # 12211) on :
 
the language of the state is Arabic and the supream culture is Arab
 
Posted by Hikuptah (Member # 11131) on :
 
Ausar Arab culture to Amr is Riding a Kamel wearing Jaalabiya and speaking Arabic and caring a sword if this is what an Arab is then i would say the Whole HOrn of Africa is Arab and so is West AFrica and the Whole NOrth AFrica so Africa is mostly Arab from WEst North and East.
 
Posted by AMR1 (Member # 7651) on :
 
Arab culture

From poetry, novels, system of the house/family, marriage traditions, other ceremonies, traditions in relation to marrige and women. The list is endless.
 
Posted by AMR1 (Member # 7651) on :
 
Sudan is 80% Arabic, the Cia State in its web, it is 70%. You can not expect the CIA TO GIVE THE RIGHT NUMBER FOR ITS ENEMIES.

At least it showed that the Beja are not considered black like black darfurians in the Sudan.
 
Posted by rasol (Member # 4592) on :
 
Black Beja, Black Dafurians...they all have you demoralised.
 
Posted by AMR1 (Member # 7651) on :
 
By the way the Sudanese army sends Southern battalion to Darfur and send Darfurians to fight the South. No northerners die there.

The Beja are in fact Nubians , not arabized, but our people, and in fact they and arab Saudi-sudanese rebelled together against Khartoum, but it is solved now.
 
Posted by Africa (Member # 12142) on :
 
Sudan is not an Arab country, Arab Sudanese are the minority, they can't send Arabs to the front...there is not enough Arab in the army...you know it...Sudan is a Black African Nation...the referendum in Southern Sudan is coming Sudan...and for Darfur, things don't look good for the Sudanese government...

plan2replan Copyright © 2006 Africa
 
Posted by ausar (Member # 1797) on :
 
Amr, could you be more specific about Arab culture than just poetry,marriage customs,novels,ceremonies,etc. Also point out how these are influenced by Arabs or shared with other Arabic people on the Arabian peninsula.

I also asked you what Arabic culture was?


So describe for me what is Arabic about northern Sudanese culture?
 
Posted by Arwa (Member # 11172) on :
 
^Ausar,

Be gentle to our friend AMR1. We don't want his brain to  -
 
Posted by Djehuti (Member # 6698) on :
 
^^LOL [Big Grin] Arabisation has already done that to his brain!

quote:
Originally posted by Sudan is an Arab country:

the language of the state is Arabic and the supream culture is Arab

[Embarrassed] And can you please explain how Arab is a "supreme" culture when native Africans have created civilizations in that area long before 'Arabs' even existed?? (of course I expect no answer to this question as well [Wink] )
 
Posted by dawit (Member # 12134) on :
 
If Habeshas or Somalis lived in Sudan and didnt want Arabism would they be under 'Black' or Arab or own thing like Beja?
 
Posted by Africa (Member # 12142) on :
 
Don't jump to conclusions, the CIA classified them in their own category, but read how that supposed Sudanese view the Beja:

quote:

Sudan is an Arab country
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
These Beja people were not originally blacks, what do blacks know abour horses and camels.

They have just turned dark due to their closeness to the real Blacks

Apparently he doesn't like too much their color, which is much darker, often very dark compare to some Arab Sudanese.

And I don't think Horners would be categorized as Arab as the following poster wrote:
quote:
Makaahil

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Sudan is an Arab country:
These Beja people were not originally blacks, what do blacks know abour horses and camels.

They have just turned dark due to their closeness to the real Blacks
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 -
 -


There you have it, blacks with horses and camels.

plan2replan Copyright © 2006 Africa
 
Posted by Africa (Member # 12142) on :
 
up because it's the same issue as American...this thread represesent Beja, Dinkas, Nuers and other othe Africans who fought for their culture....We are African...we don't don't care about Europeans...about Arabs...about Asians....but if you close this threat, we'll fight back....
plan2replan Copyright © 2006 Africa
 
Posted by Supercar (Member # 6477) on :
 
^Distortions of African history, not just Kemet, was a component of European imperialism. Naturally, these long discredited claims will find expression in reactionary sections of European societies and their projeny. But if as you say, don't care about such folks, then let them be the ones to step up to the plate and challenge scholarly material that disseminate through boards like this one. It should not be the aim of the objective to chase after reactionary ideologues and emboldening them, by dedicating and wasting threads on them.
 
Posted by Africa (Member # 12142) on :
 
Ask Yonis or Doug,
I'm a christian and Black African, I don't need to tell you my backgroun...whether it's George Bush, Donald Rumsfeld or Dick Cheney...we don't know them... we don't care...we have other problems...why they deleted all the threads related to America???

plan2replan Copyright © 2006 Africa
 
Posted by Hikuptah (Member # 11131) on :
 
In this forum we speak of European Imperialism but we never Speak about Arab Nationalism and Arab Imperialism and how it changed the Nile Valley and Africa.
 
Posted by Africa (Member # 12142) on :
 
I'm an African Christian...but I would like to ask you what's the difference between African tribal tensions and Americas's tribal tensions???
plan2replan Copyright © 2006 Africa

[ 26. October 2006, 09:23 PM: Message edited by: Horus_Den_1 ]
 
Posted by Africa (Member # 12142) on :
 
up
 
Posted by Hikuptah (Member # 11131) on :
 
Africa let me mention something to u the people of AFrica are more culturally tied to the people of the EAst than the people of the WEst Africans have more incommon with Arabs and Southeast Asians than they do with AFrican Americans & Westerners Europeans & Americans. Well AFrica for start off the African Tribal tensions are way older than the American one they tend to be about class and about land.
 
Posted by Africa (Member # 12142) on :
 
What's your point? I'm from Africa...European=White Bantus....Africans...look like Sans...Tutsis...Bantus....my point is that non Africans look like Africans...Basically there is nothing original about European(they have bigger noses compared to Elongated Eastern African, nothing original about Asiansn(they have less slanted eyes compared to Sans)
plan2replan Copyright © 2006 Africa
 


(c) 2015 EgyptSearch.com

Powered by UBB.classic™ 6.7.3