...
Post A Reply
my profile
|
directory
login
|
register
|
search
|
faq
|
forum home
»
EgyptSearch Forums
»
Egyptology
»
Natufians were cold-adapted
» Post A Reply
Post A Reply
Login Name:
Password:
Message Icon:
Message:
HTML is not enabled.
UBB Code™ is enabled.
[QUOTE]Originally posted by Kalonji: [QB] [QUOTE]Originally posted by MindoverMatter718: What you're doing is excluding samples as being representative of Natufians becuase they contrast, my point is the contrast is logical considering the Natufian origins. [/QUOTE]Yeah, keep making desperate accusations. [QUOTE]Originally posted by MindoverMatter718: How do you know they practiced Natufian culture? Where is this stated in the document? How do you know they aren't Natufians? [/QUOTE]^LOL, people, this is a prime example of someone who is arguing with what he is hearing in his head, instead of what is actually said. It is clear that by me saying: [i]4 crania from the African component that practiced Natufians culture[/i] That I was simply referring to them (the four crania) belonging to Natufians, but the turd thinks in his mind that I am talking about extra-terrestrials or something. What on earth do you think the ‘’component’’ word refers to? Component of what? Natufians of course, you turd. [QUOTE]Originally posted by MindoverMatter718: The above along with all other data tells me that the Natufians not displaying a tropically adapted body plan akin to modern tropical Africans, doesnt necessarily insinuate that they can not still align with Africans cranio-facially or that Natufians became African later on. [/QUOTE]You are officially talking out of your neck. You make absolutely no sense. Can you show me [b]ONE[/b] example where two populations as distinct as Mesolithic Nile valley specimens and Mesolithic Eurasians mix, and come out still resembling the African extreme craniofacially? **Sigh**. He still doesn’t realize that the African extreme is noted in samples that were predominantly eerrrr….. African. LOL. How do I know this? Dude.. the samples described by Keith Brace and Angel make no mention of appearing mixed, and even more so, these late comers with African affinity all had several things in common, and that is that they had occipital buns, dolichocephalic calvaria, broad nasal aperatures, prognathism, lack of prominent chins, and that they were short statured (like later dynastic Egyptians) and had thick thighbones according to Keith. These features distinguish these latecomers from the Eurasian Natufians that were already present. Your entire ‘’mixed but with African cranio-facial features’’ theory goes out the window. I now know that your obsessive need to make Natufians in general cranio-facially like Brace’s Niger Congo speakers is intrinsically linked to your co creation and mixed race fantasy. MOMs reasoning: Cranio facially they have to display this one thing, in order for me to keep believing - in the face of evidence to the contrary - that there were no Natufians before these ‘’negroid’’ folks. If I accept that Natufians did not always resemble Niger Congo speakers, I might have to deal with the thought that there were Natufians before the African migration. [QUOTE]Originally posted by MindoverMatter718: This is logical, and most likely to happen when a population from SW Asia and Africa combine. [/QUOTE]LOLLLL. WRONG. Note what I wrote about the Lachish population above, and how they averaged out near the Magrebian sample used in Keita’s plot, even though Gabonese, Kermatians, Badarians and dynastic Egyptians were available to cluster with. [QUOTE]Originally posted by MindoverMatter718: How do you know exactly that it doesnt take the Eurasian component into account? I'll wait for this evidence...[/QUOTE]I now know you are completely ignorant about the literature on the Natufians. Do you even read or do you just skim through it? According to Brace: [i]If the Late Pleistocene Natufian sample from Israel is the source from which that Neolithic spread was derived, then there was clearly a SubSaharan African element present [b]of almost equal importance as the Late Prehistoric Eurasian element.[/b] - Brace[/i] [/QB][/QUOTE]
Instant Graemlins
Instant UBB Code™
What is UBB Code™?
Options
Disable Graemlins in this post.
*** Click here to review this topic. ***
Contact Us
|
EgyptSearch!
(c) 2015 EgyptSearch.com
Powered by UBB.classic™ 6.7.3