...
Post A Reply
my profile
|
directory
login
|
register
|
search
|
faq
|
forum home
»
EgyptSearch Forums
»
Egyptology
»
Asar Imhotep's book Nsw.t Bjt.j
» Post A Reply
Post A Reply
Login Name:
Password:
Message Icon:
Message:
HTML is not enabled.
UBB Code™ is enabled.
[QUOTE]Originally posted by Fourty2Tribes: [QB] [QUOTE]Originally posted by Khepera9evolution: WHICH ONE OF THOSE SCHOLARS PROVED IT TO ACADEMIA? NOT ONE... ITS PSEUDOSCIENCE... I KNOW PEOPLE THAT SAY EVOLUTION ISN'T REAL AND PROVIDES WHAT THEY CALL EVIDENCE, BUT NOT ONE OF THEM HAS DEBATED SCHOLARS AND EXPERTS OR PROVED IT TO THE WORLD AT CONFERENCES AND SCHOLASTIC FORUMS.... GOOGLE TRANSLATE LMAO OMG.. I CAN SEE RIGHT NOW YOU'RE JUST A FAN OF ASAR[/QUOTE]Back in caps?? [IMG]http://i0.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/000/346/741/fde.jpg[/IMG] I just gave you Ntr Neb's demonstration which I fact checked. A person that team Osiris regards as a linguist https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ws6Hhguxd88. The thing I like about Neb as a teacher is he is really good at sourcing. http://www.academia.edu/34440586/Ancient_Language_Dictionary_Corpus I gave you Asar's pieces on the word god which I also fact checked. I gave you two scholars on wikipedia that came to the same conclusion when they challenged the model-halfass. Clyde gave such a long list the mods called it spam. You are giving nothing but appeals to authority vs evidence. That is pseudo. I asked for a proto breakdown of Greenberg's families. Where are they? [QUOTE] THIS IS EXACTLY WHY EXPERTS ARE EXPERTS AND AMATEURS ARE AMATEURS... HOW DO YOU CONNECT AN LANGUAGE ISOLATE TO PEOPLE THAT AREN'T EVEN REMOTELY KIN TO ANYONE IN THE NIGER-CONGO? JUST STOP IT... THEY ALSO SAY THAT SUMERIAN (ANOTHER LANGUAGE ISOLATE) IS NIGER-CONGO... JESUS CHRIST! LMAO [/QUOTE]That's because it is. People have known about the relationship to the languages Greenberg called Niger Congo and Sumarian for a long time. I already gave you academic sources... Is academia.edu an academic source? http://www.academia.edu/7385390/Sumerians_Iberians_and_Basques_-_A_continuum [QUOTE] Sumerians, Iberians and Basques – A continuum P180614 Page 1 Sumerians, Iberians and Basques – A continuum By Matthias Ifejika Email: matthias.ifejika@gmail.com Abstract The Basque language is often touted as a language isolate yet a careful study of the language shows that it is related to Sumerian. The many features of Basque reveal that it is derived from a Niger-Congo language, which I have been able to identify as Igbo. In this brief expose, I show how some of its words had been derived [/QUOTE]That's called collaborating evidence. It goes back to Willibald Wanger 1935 https://www.amazon.com/Comparative-Lexical-Study-Sumerian-Bantu/dp/B00086IK1C Since you have had Winters, Hermstein, Ifejika Walker, Imhotep, Dunn, Neb. But they are all wrong because of Greenberg? That is what I mean about being discerning. That is what was wrong with the video. The Greenberg families have no proto languages yet they argue that Niger-Congo languages, which people have demonstrated since the 30s are related to OoA languages is younger and begin in west Africa. https://nigercongoindoeuropean.net/ language [CODE] English———-Basque—————African Languages Ditch————‘Zanga’————–‘Tsanya’ [Hausa] Stone————‘Harri’—————‘Hayre’ [Fula] Skin————-‘Larru’—————‘Larral’ [Fula] Skin————-‘Larru’—————‘Ara’ [Yoruba] True————-‘Egiazko’————-‘Gaskiya’ [Hausa] Forgive———–‘Barka’————–‘Gbaghara’ [Igbo] Snake————-‘Suge’—————‘Zoka’ [Zaramo] Snake————-‘Suge’—————‘NZoka’ [Sukuma] Snake————-‘Suge’————-‘InZoka’[Luhya,Kinyarwanda,Kirundi] Bird—————‘Txori’—————‘Tsoli’ [Punu] Bird—————‘Txori’—————‘Sholli’ [‘birds’ – Fula] Twenty———–‘(H)ogei’————-‘Ugie’ [Edo] Twenty———–‘(H)ogei’————-‘No:gay’ [Fula] Twenty———–‘(H)ogei’————-‘Noogaj’ [Fula] Meat————-‘(H)aragi’————‘Eran Jije’ [Yoruba] Meat————-‘(H)aragi’————‘Arizh’ [Nubian] Rope————-‘Soka’—————‘Sugey’ [Songhai] Shout————‘(O)ihu’————–‘Ihu’ [Hausa] Child————-‘Ume’————–‘Omo’ [Yoruba & Edo] Knife————-‘Labana’————‘Labi’ [Fula] Knife————-‘Labana’————‘Lobe’ [‘dagger’ – Yoruba] Trap————–‘Lakirio’————‘Qrra’ [Tamazight Berber] There————-‘Han’————–‘Lohun’ [Yoruba] Ash—————‘Errau(ts)’———-‘Eeru’ [Yoruba] We—————-‘Gu’————–‘Gu’,‘Ku’, [Kpelle] We—————-‘Gu’————–‘Ku’ [Guro, Yaure] Blood————–‘(O)dol’————‘Dyoli’ [Malinke, Dyula] Blood————–‘(O)dol’————‘Dyolo’ [Bolo] Seed—————‘(H)azi’————‘Sii’ [Mandinka] Seed—————‘(H)azi’————‘Si’ [Khassonke, Malinke, Bambara] Knee—————‘Bel(h)aun’———‘Kum-balin’ [Khassonke] Knee—————‘Bel(h)aun’———‘Kum-balino’ [Mandinka] Arrow————–‘Gezi’————–‘Bine-kise’ [Bambara] Arrow—————‘Gezi’————–‘kèsé’/’kese’/’kēsé’[Baraïn, E.Chadic] I——————-‘Ni’—————‘Nii’ [Hausa] Red—————–‘Gorri’————‘Cirey’ [Songhai] Mud—————-‘Loka(tz)’———-‘Laka’ [Hausa] Foot—————-‘(H)oin’———–‘Koyn-gal’ [Fula] Wind—————‘(H)aize’———-‘Azwu’ [Tamazight Berber] Wind—————‘(H)aize’———-‘Ess-i’ [Nubian] Black—————‘Bel(tz)’———–‘Bal-ejum’ [Fula] Meal—————-‘Baskari’———-‘Gari’ [Hausa] Two—————–‘Bi’————–‘Biyu’ [Hausa] Jump—————-‘Salto’———–‘Tsalle’ [Hausa] Menstruation, period—‘Hileko’———-‘Haila’ [Hausa] Short—————-‘(La)bur’———‘Obere’ [Igbo] Cloud—————-‘Hodei’———-‘Gude’ [Yoruba] Cloud—————-‘Hodei’———-‘Kuiti’ & ‘Kidi’ [Tedaga] Lobster————–‘(O)tarraina’——-‘Ndeerindeerino’ [Mandinka] Shrimp————–‘(O)tarrainska’—–‘Ndeerindeerino’ [Mandinka] Hoof—————-‘Apatxhari’——–‘Patako’ [Yoruba] Woman————–‘Emakumea’——‘Kamu’ [Kanuri] Old——————‘Zahar’———-‘Tsoho’ [Hausa] Town—————-‘Hiri’,‘Herri’——‘Gari’ [Hausa] Wife—————–‘Emazte’———‘Mata’ [Hausa] Fish—————–‘Arrain’———‘Hari’ [Songhai] Rain—————–‘Euri’————‘Are’, ‘Ari’ [Nubian] Bark—————–‘Azal’———–‘Azi’ [Nubian] Foot——————‘(H)oin’———‘O:y’ [Nubian] Round—————-‘Biribil’———‘Obirikiti’ [Yoruba] And——————‘Eta’————‘Ati’ [Yoruba] Dog——————‘Txakur’———‘Kare’ [Hausa] Leg——————‘Hanka’———-‘Tanka’ [Wolof] Chief—————–‘Buru-zagi’——-‘Sarki’ [Hausa] Yawn—————–‘Aharrausi’——-‘Uhere’ [Igbo] [Water] Spring———‘Iturburu’——–‘Asuburu’ [Twi] Bay——————-‘Badia’——–‘Baadaa’ [‘seaside’/’beach’ in Mandinka] Elbow—————–‘Ukondo’——-‘Conco’ [Wolof] Go——————–‘Jo[h]an’——-‘Jah-a’/‘Jan-a’ [Fula] Earth, Ground———-‘Lur’———–‘Lo’ [Bobo] Earth, Ground———-‘Lur’———–‘Lwoe’ [Kpelle] Path, Way————-‘Bide’———-‘Beda’ [‘large road’ in Khassonke & Bambara] Night—————–‘Gau’———–‘Gue’ [Bozo] Name—————–‘Izen’———-‘Isem’ [Tuareg Berber] To Lie Down————‘Etzan’———‘Ettes’ [‘sleep’ in Tuareg] Wood(en)————-‘Zur-ezko’——‘(I)sarir’ [Tuareg] [/CODE][QUOTE] I DON'T NEED YOUR CONJECTURE AND STOP TRYING TO BE CAPTAIN SAVE A PSEUDO... ASAR IMHOTEP SAID THAT THESE LANGUAGES >>>MUTUALLY<<< INFLUENCED EACH OTHER. MEANING THAT COPTIC INFLUENCED MIDDLE EGYPTIAN AND MIDDLE EGYPTIAN INFLUENCED COPTIC AS HE PUTS "SIDE BY SIDE" THOSE ARE HIS WORDS... PLEASE STOP COMMENTING... [/QUOTE] :eek: I see why you mad. Because I cut through your BS. You jumped off your original claims to something else. Then made a big deal about the something else. I think you are Johnathan from team Osiris because that type of paper tiger emotion is what was in the video. At least you made a funny with captain save a pseudo but its still childish. I never said that Imhotep and Mboli did not claim that Coptic wasn't spoken at the same time as ME just not Coptic as we know it. Thus the crux of their argument and the only thing that is really new about their argument is the two languages. [QUOTE] ASAR SAID HIMSELF THAT THEY IDENTIFIED WITH PEOPLE FROM THE AEGEAN SEA. HE SAID HIMSELF IN HIS BOOK THAT COPTIC IS A RESULT OF BORROWINGS FROM MIDDLE EGYPTIAN SPEAKERS AND HE ALSO SAYS IF THEY WERE INDIGENOUS THEY WOULDN'T HAVE TO BORROW ANY GREEK CHARACTERS TO WRITE THEIR SCRIPT... BRO I KNOW YOU DIDN'T READ THE BOOK BECAUSE IM QUOTING DIRECTLY FROM HIS BOOK VERBATIM ON WHAT HE SAYS ABOUT COPTS AND COPTIC. [/QUOTE]Swenet just posted Mboli's model. As you can see Coptic is an indigenous African language, related to other African languages, that according to Asar was spoken in ancient times. Your lack of reading comprehension is amazing. If Asar is already telling you by citing Mboli that Coptic is an indigenous Egyptian language when he mentions borrowing from ME speakers he is talking about the other languages of Egypt. When he says foreigners using a different script he is talking about people who look like this [IMG]https://static.euronews.com/articles/354271/400x225_354271.jpg[/IMG] they may be speaking an indigenous language but you can tell they aren't from there because they are using a foreign script. [QUOTE] AND LMAO AT SOMEBODY ON FACEBOOK DEBUNKING A LANGUAGE FAMILY THAT EVEN EXPERTS HAVE NOT TO DATE... IM SO GLAD IM NOT AFROCENTRIC LMAO [/QUOTE]This right here is why you fail. This is what leads to circular reasoning. Its the same as when Dr. Ali Muhammad says he refuses to believe in evolution. Its been a buckdancy day today. I'm so glad daddy didn't raise a sambo. This is why team Osiris would never debate Asar Imhotep. They go full emo and throw hissy fits. Happened here... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W0-yhc4CoN8 [/QB][/QUOTE]
Instant Graemlins
Instant UBB Code™
What is UBB Code™?
Options
Disable Graemlins in this post.
*** Click here to review this topic. ***
Contact Us
|
EgyptSearch!
(c) 2015 EgyptSearch.com
Powered by UBB.classic™ 6.7.3