17% Hmmm Was Nat-Geo only counting the West Asian portion of Arabs and not the recombined African?
Arabs were the only people to invade twice, maybe 2.5 times. Ahmn jus sayin .
xyyman Member # 13597
posted
You know the chart is not from NG but DNATribes?
I posted this many times. west Asians are the Turks. Look at the population dataset. Also Sahara_Arabians are the indigenous North Africans/Amazigh and Arab Bedouins we know are the remnants of the African Natufians.
Fourty2Tribes Member # 21799
posted
I know it's DnaTribes. I don't think you emphasized how it demonstrated how gentrified modern Egypt is. Modern Egypt is more Arabian than North African. That contradicts Nat-Geo.
That's the topic. Tribes says modern Egyptians are 42% Arabian. Nat-Geo has them at 17%. Major difference. I think Tribes is more accurate because they show all their work.
xyyman Member # 13597
posted
Another interesting point is ...."west Asian' are not "Arabs" per DNATribes. So the label "Arabs' can become convoluted. So Mike was on the right track.
posted 
![[Wink]](wink.gif)
.