quote:
ausar wrote:
I guess you are basing this (The Obelisk is an Ancient Egyptian Phallic Symbol) off of the fact that Set cut off Ausar's penis and that Auset built him a new penis that was swalloed by fish in the Nile river.
Some debate about this because some Egyptologist believe that the obeliskes are really rays from the sun and tie within the Helopolitan Cosmology which started to gain influence around the 5th dyansty. The proto-type for these obeliske can be seen on sun temples in areas like Abusir.
No,
I base my conclusion on two concrete factors:
1) The Mdu Ntr
It should be clear by now that I place the highest priority on the very words of the Ancient Egyptians themselves, all other evidence is secondary:
Ben - "copulate"
Benu - "male"
Benn - "copulate, beget, begotten, virile, phallus"
Benen - "god of regeneration"; a form of Menu
Benni - a phallic god
Benben - "to copulate"
Benben - to well up
Benben - to hasten, to come
Benben - the stone symbolic of the Sun-god; obelisk; pyramid
Benben.t - top of pyramid
I interpret the above to reveal the concept of:
male reproductive organs (penis/testicles) > obelisk > pyramid > tomb > regeneration
and as Super car has also pointed out above; "wherever archaeological investigations have been possible there is a case for suggesting that stelae and tombs are directly associated. - by Dr. Stuart Munro-Hay."
The African concept of death and regeneration...
2) ordinary observation
the obvious..
Here's an image from Google images > "phallic symbol", it's the Washington Monument - http://www.remnantofgod.org/washmon.jpg
From the World Book Online:
"Washington Monument is a great obelisk built in honor of George Washington. It stands in Washington, D.C., near the Potomac River, about halfway between the Capitol and the Lincoln Memorial.
The monument has the shape of the obelisks of ancient Egypt, but it is several times larger than they were."
Other phallic examples can be found in the famous Moorish Spanish architecture: http://www.austingurl.com/images/Moorish%20window.jpg
http://www.escapeartist.com/efam/52/moorish.gif
and the not so obvious
Alfred Hitchcock in his classic film "North by Northwest" managed to pull a fast one on the censors. At the end of the film when Cary Grant kisses Eva Marie Saint on the train, Hitch cuts to the exterior and there's a shot of the train entering a dark tunnel. Hitch would later chuckle, "That was my phallic symbol!"
[This message has been edited by Wally (edited 25 April 2005).]