EgyptSearch Forums: Akenathon - Good or Bad Pharaoh?

This is topic Akenathon - Good or Bad Pharaoh? in forum Living in Egypt at EgyptSearch Forums.

To visit this topic, use this URL:
http://www.egyptsearch.com/forums/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=2;t=002786

Posted by Lori (Member # 2390) on :

After reading "The Egyptian" by Mika Waltari and viewing a series on Discovery Channel on Tutankhamun, I understood Akhenaton was hated by Egyptians for trying to replace gods and undermine the power of the priests. But was that a bad thing?

How is he viewed today by historians and especially by Egyptians?

------------------
In Love With Egypt

Posted by Monica (Member # 2621) on :

Hi Lori,

I can suggest, the following book:

'Eternel Egypt: Pharoahs, Caesars, Caliphs & Sultans', by Max Rodenbeck and 4 other writers. (2002 edition)

Also, you may find replies to your questions if your topic is transferred to the Ancient Egypt forum on ES. Ausar would certainly reply!

Best regards,

Monica

Posted by Lori (Member # 2390) on :

quote:
Originally posted by Monica:
Hi Lori,
I can suggest, the following book:
'Eternel Egypt: Pharoahs, Caesars, Caliphs & Sultans', by Max Rodenbeck and 4 other writers. (2002 edition)
Also, you may find replies to your questions if your topic is transferred to the Ancient Egypt forum on ES. Ausar would certainly reply!
Best regards,
Monica

Thanks Monica! How do I get the topic transferred?

Anyway I do not want to read another book, I want real replies of LIVING people

Cheers,
Lori

------------------
In Love With Egypt

Posted by Monica (Member # 2621) on :

Lori...

Open a thread with your same topic, on the Ancient Egypt forum, or write a message to ausar and he will transfer it!

Hope you get interesting answers, ausar, as well as Dr. Al Saadawi, are usually very eloquent regarding the subject matter!

Take care,

Monica

[This message has been edited by Monica (edited 16 January 2004).]

Posted by Lori (Member # 2390) on :

Monica, thanks a LOT I transferred the topic and now I have some knowledgeable answers.

I think I will stay more in Ancient Egypt there are nice people writing there

Lori

------------------
In Love With Egypt

Posted by Monica (Member # 2621) on :

Lori!

I'm happy you did. One thing for sure, some of the members that post on the Ancient Egypt forum, REALLY know what they're talking about. Some debates are a bit lengthy, but they are focused on the subject matter, and that reflects their passion towards Egypt.

I also find that ausar is very dedicated, you will notice a very thorough research in his posts, and a lot of tolerance and patience too.

When you have a chance, check Al Saadawi's website. He was actually invited on that forum by ausar.
http://alsaadawi.exeedia.com

Interesting and enriching info, friend!

Enjoy!
Monica

[This message has been edited by Monica (edited 20 January 2004).]